Nintendo, one of the world's largest makers of video game players, won a U.S. appeals court decision in a patent case that will allow it to keep importing its popular Wii system into the United States. Monday's decision by the U.S. Federal Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C. affirmed a January 2012 ruling by the U.S. International Trade Commission, which handles many technology patent disputes.
Nintendo successful in its appeal to the U.S. Courts
The decision against Motiva LLC, which sued Nintendo in 2008, could make it harder for U.S. companies to halt imports of products that allegedly infringe patents on grounds they want to establish a “domestic industry” for similar products.
In January, in a patent dispute between InterDigital inc
Motiva, which is based in Dublin, Ohio, had claimed that Wii infringed two patents for a system to track a game user's position and body movement.
A three-judge Federal Circuit panel agreed with the ITC that the main impetus behind Motiva's litigation against Kyoto, Japan-based Nintendo was to win damages or a settlement, not to license or make products incorporating Motiva's patents. This panel said Motiva's litigation did not amount to the “significant” or “substantial” investment toward commercializing patented technology that was required under a patent protection law, known as the Tariff Act, that sets limits on imports.
“The evidence demonstrated that Motiva's litigation was targeted at financial gains, not at encouraging adoption of Motiva's patented technology,” Circuit Judge Sharon Prost wrote. “There is simply no reasonable likelihood that, after successful litigation against Nintendo, Motiva's patented technology would have been licensed by partners who would have incorporated it.”
Christopher Banys, a lawyer for Motiva, called the decision “unfortunate” but said the case will continue. “We are confident that Motiva will be vindicated when its case is tried in district court,” he said. Mark Davies, a lawyer who argued the appeal for Nintendo, did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Wii's major competitors include Sony Corp's PlayStation and Microsoft Corp's