A U.S. public interest group asked a federal court on Wednesday to block Google Inc
Google, whose offerings include its flagship search engine, Gmail, YouTube and Google+ products, announced last month that it was unifying its numerous product-specific privacy policies. The company stressed in subsequent announcements that the changes would not allow for any new or additional data collection and said that most of its product-specific policies already allowed information to be shared across product lines when users were signed onto their Google accounts.
“We've undertaken the most extensive notification effort in Google's history to ensure that users have many opportunities to learn about the changes,” a Google spokesman said in a statement.
When the new policy comes into effect on March 1, information from most Google products will be treated as a single trove of data, which the company could use for targeted advertising. EPIC's lawsuit argues that Google misrepresented its privacy practices by not disclosing the benefits advertisers would reap from access to the consolidated data of users.
The aggregated data would allow advertisers to better target their ads, “and therefore Google's new business practices increase the commercial value of a given user's data,” the court filing said.
The group also challenged Google's claim it is not collecting any new information. Aggregated data would give advertisers access to information about users that they were not privy to before, such as logged-in users' YouTube search histories, EPIC said.
“Thus, Google will share new or additional information with third-party advertisers without first obtaining 'express affirmative consent' from Google users,” EPIC charged in court documents. EPIC said the court must act to protect Internet users and prevent, “the hazard that consumers will obtain relief under a FTC order, only to be left without recourse if the Commission fails to enforce its order.”
An FTC spokeswoman said: “The FTC takes compliance with our consent orders very seriously and always looks carefully at any evidence that they are being violated.” The Google spokesman said the company had not seen the filing so could not comment on the specifics. He added: “Protecting people's privacy is something we think about all day across the company and we welcome discussions about our approach.”